Rogan's claim rests on a timeline mismatch: comparing Obama's entire 8-year deportation record (3.1M) to Trump's first 14 months (~932K). The raw number is technically true, but it's misleading framing—it's like saying 'More people graduated college in 2000-2008 than in 2024 alone.' Clinton's immigration rhetoric from 2007 was strict, but comparing old words to current Trump policy execution isn't the same comparison. Trump's current enforcement (reported 3M self-deportations plus removals) shows intensity, just through different methods.